Mind And Body Philosophy Essay Example

+ All Mind-Body Problem Essays:

  • The Evolution of a Woman's Body Image
  • Remarkable Minds: The Influence of Great Texts
  • Essay on the Dark Side of the Mind Exposed in Cask of Amontillado
  • The Benifits of Dance On the Human Body
  • Body Mass Index
  • How Lack of Sleep Affects the Human Body
  • Use of Energy by the Human Body
  • Women and Body Image
  • Consciousness and Philosophers of the Mind
  • The Representation of the Body in Blade Runner
  • Selling Body Shame
  • Population Problem in Bangladesh
  • Management And The Body Shop
  • Body Modifications: Tattoos and Body Piercings
  • The Practice of Body Piercing
  • Theories of resurrection of the body are logically incoherent.
  • Confessions of a Second-Rate Mind
  • Plank, Einstein and Black Body Radiation
  • Body Image
  • Problem of Evil
  • The Human Mind and The Computer
  • Salt in Moderation is Good for the Body
  • Human Body Systems
  • Body Shop Evolution of Business in Society
  • Can a Computer Have a Mind?
  • Body Language
  • Goffman's Thesis on the Stigmatized Body
  • Verbal Persuasion and Body Language
  • The Problem with “Hamlet and His Problems”
  • Article Analysis of 'Habits of Mind'
  • How to Manage Your Body to Improve Your Mind
  • Theory of Mind
  • Theories of the Unconscious Mind
  • Analysis of Movie " a Beautiful Mind"
  • Music and the Mind
  • Secrets of the Mind
  • Analysis of the Film, A Beautiful Mind
  • Gilbert Ryle's The Concept of Mind
  • The Function and Importance of the Liver in the Body
  • H.G> Well's The Stolen Body
  • A Beautiful Mind (Movie)
  • Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer
  • Fasting: Body Cleansing or Starving
  • Sanity: Boundaries of the Mind
  • Crawling Inside the Mind of Shakespeare's Hamlet
  • The Criminal Mind by Dr. Adrian Raine
  • The Main Problems of Lexicography
  • Mind Is Not a Vessel to Be Filled, but a Fire to Be Kindled
  • Poverty Is a State of Mind
  • Absorbent Mind - Essay
  • Habit 2: Begin with the End in Mind
  • Society's Problem with Physical Appearance
  • Report of 2013 Bodies Exhibition
  • Media and Body Image
  • Body Image in the Media
  • Mind and Matrix
  • Gandhi, Satyagraha, and the Western Mind
  • Hold Up Problem
  • Zen and the Enlightened Mind
  • Body Art
  • The Importance of Demonstrating Good Body Language
  • Schizophrenia, A splitting of the mind
  • The Development of a Criminal Mind
  • Transcendentalism: The Philosophy Of The Mind
  • The Mind of a Serial Killer
  • Descartes' Views on the Topic of Philosophy of Mind
  • The Effects of Methamphetamine on the Body
  • The Mind and Motivation of a Serial Killer
  • The Relationship Between Visuality, the Body, and Knowledge in the Film Memento
  • Implantation of Rfid in Human Body
  • Success is a Subjective State of Mind
  • A Beautiful Mind
  • The Body Shop Case#8
  • “an Idle Mind Is the Devil’s Workshop”
  • Downfall of Female Body Image: Media’s Influence
  • Overpopulation a Problem?
  • The Discovery of the First Bog Body
  • Alcohol and Its Effects on the Body
  • A Study on Leibniz's Philosophy of Mind
  • Regulatory Bodies of the Education Sector
  • The Perception of Korean Women Bodies
  • Real-Life Problem Faced by the Body Shop
  • Kant, the Body, and Knowledge
  • Leibniz and the Problem of Evil
  • Marketing for Bath and Body Works
  • Caffeine: Does it Harm the Body?
  • Progeria: Adolescents Living in the Bodies of the Elderly
  • The Effects of Alcohol on the Body

This is a sample of our (approximately) 4 page long Essay Descartes Mind And Body Argument notes, which we sell as part of the History of Philosophy Notes collection, a 1st Class package written at University Of Oxford in 2011 that contains (approximately) 46 pages of notes across 10 different documents.

Essay Descartes Mind And Body Argument Revision

The following is a plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our History of Philosophy Notes. This text version has had its formatting removed so pay attention to its contents alone rather than its presentation. The version you download will have its original formatting intact and so will be much prettier to look at.

'Does Descartes give any good arguments in the Meditations for distinguishing mind and body?' The 'real distinction' between mind and body in the Meditations centres around Meditations II and VI. In Meditation VI Descartes outlines his major argument for the distinction, using foundations that had in part been laid in Meditation II. The title question asks us to consider whether the arguments Descartes lays out are 'good', which we can take to mean, more specifically, 'sound', and equally, we can understand 'distinguishing mind and body' to mean Descartes' ultimate aim of proving that one's mind and one's body are two distinctly separate substances. Central to the essay, then, will be a presentation of Descartes' main argument for the distinction, an elucidation of the various aspects or implications of the argument that require clarification, and an assessment of why the argument ultimately fails. The groundwork for Descartes' principle mind-body argument in the Meditations was laid in his argument on a similar theme in the Discourse on Method. In the Discourse, Descartes argues that the mind can be known to be a substance distinct from the body by reference to the fact that the existence of the material world can be doubted, while the existence of the mind, as at least a thinking thing, cannot. This argument is, however, obviously fallacious, as Hatfield's 'Zorro' analogy indicates1:

1. I cannot doubt the existence of Zorro, since he is standing in front of me.

2. I can doubt the existence of Don Diego: for all I know, he might have died suddenly, very recently.

3. Therefore, Zorro cannot be Don Diego. This argument clearly does not work, since it is epistemically possible that Zorro and Don Diego are the same person, and by the same token, Descartes' argument fails. In Meditations, then, Descartes attempted to prepare a more robust argument, looking to strengthen his position by attempting to show that one can move from 'I am not aware of anything that belongs to my essence other than thought' to 'it is a fact that nothing else besides thought belongs to my essence'. The way he attempts to do this is informed by the problem that he faces, that 'the gap between subjective cognition and objective reality, once acknowledged, is not easily closed 2'. So, in Meditations, Descartes sets out to bridge this very gap. To do this, Descartes needs to show that there is some objective indicator of certainty, to justify the leap from the position that we arrive at in the second Meditation, that since we cannot doubt our own existence as a thinking thing but can doubt the existence of the external world, our concepts at least seem to present mind and body as distinct, to proving as fact that the two actually are distinct. This objective indicator Descartes attempts to find in the fifth Meditation, by arguing that ideas regarding different properties of external, material objects fall into different categories, and that some of these ideas, such as ideas about duration, extension and movement, cannot be misconstrued in a way that makes them false. For example, no matter what combination of mathematical properties one understands or utilises, the angles of a triangle will always add up to 180 degrees. These sort of ideas Descartes places into the category of 'clear and distinct' understanding. In the fourth Meditation also, Descartes appears to imply a similar notion, that 'everything that we clearly and distinctly 1

G Hatfield, Descartes and the Meditations, London (2003), p247 J Cottingham, Cartesian Dualism: Theology, Metaphysics and Science, in J Cottingham (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Descartes, Cambridge (1998), p245 2

****************************End Of Sample*****************************

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our History of Philosophy Notes.

Related History Of Philosophy Samples:

0 Thoughts to “Mind And Body Philosophy Essay Example

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *